In the comments to follow, it is assumed that the saints meet together in accordance with 1 Cor. 14 on ground which leaves scope for the Holy Spirit to lead to a hymn by one, prayer by another, or a word of exhortation or doctrine by a third. Now it is obvious that if room is left for the Spirit to use whomever He will for the edifying of the body, this cannot be done without affording opportunity for forwardness and self-sufficiency to act without any guidance of the Spirit at all. Hence it is important to know how to distinguish between that which is of the flesh and that which is of the Spirit.
I would now suggest some of the broad and principal landmarks by which we may distinguish the guidance of the Spirit from fleshly counterfeits and pretensions. First, let us consider several things which are not a warrant for our taking part in conducting the meetings of the saints.
Negative Marks
The mere circumstance of there being liberty to act is no warrant for acting. The fact that there is no formal hindrance to anyone taking part in the meeting renders it possible for those whose only qualification is that they can read to take up a principal part of the time in reading chapter after chapter, and hymn after hymn. But while it is easy enough to read a chapter, to know which is the right one to read, and which is the right time to read it, is quite another matter. And to give out a hymn which really embodies and expresses the worship of the saints is what only can be done by the guidance of the Holy Spirit.
That no one else is doing anything at the time is not sufficient warrant for taking part in the meeting. On the one hand, silence for its own sake cannot be too much deprecated. It may become as complete a form as anything else. But on the other hand, silence is better than what is said or done merely to break the silence. I know well what it is to think of a good many persons present who are not in communion, perhaps not believers, and to feel uneasy at the silence on their account. Where this commonly occurs, it may be a call from God for an entirely different kind of meeting; but it can never authorize anyone to speak, or pray, or give out a hymn, for the mere sake of something being done.
Again, one’s individual state and experiences are no certain guides as to any part we may take in meetings of the saints. A hymn may have been very sweet to my own soul, or I may have been present where it has been sung with great enjoyment of the Lord’s presence. I am not to conclude from this that it is my place to give out the hymn at the next meeting I attend. There may be no suitability in it to the present state of the assembly. The hymn must be expressive of what those assembled feel, or there will be no sincerity in their joining to sing it. And who but He who knows the actual state of the assembly can guide to a hymn expressive of that state?
Then as to prayer:when one prays in the assembly, it is as the vehicle for the expression of its wants and its requests. I may have burdens of my own to cast on the Lord in prayer, which it would be very improper for me to name in the assembly. If I am led by the Spirit to pray in the assembly, I shall be enabled to offer such prayers, and make such confessions, and present such thanksgivings as are suited to the actual state of those whose mouth I become in thus addressing God.
Similarly, a portion of Scripture may have interested my own soul greatly, and I may have profited by it; however, it does not follow that I am to read it at the Lord’s table, or in other meetings of the saints. Some particular subject may be occupying my own attention greatly, and it may be well for my own soul that it should do so; but it may not be at all the subject to which God would have the attention of the saints generally drawn.
Positive Marks
Scripture gives us ample instruction as to what are the marks of true ministry. I wish now to draw your attention to some of the plainer and more obvious of these marks.
The guidance of the Spirit is not by blind impulses and unintelligent impressions, but by filling the spiritual understanding with God’s thoughts as revealed in the written Word, and by acting on the renewed affections. In early days there were indeed God’s gifts which might be in their use unconnected with spiritual intelligence. I refer to the gift of tongues where there was no interpreter. And it would appear that because this gift seemed more marvelous in men’s eyes than the others, the Corinthians were fond of using and displaying it. For this the apostle rebukes them:"I thank my God, I speak with tongues more than ye all; yet in the church I had rather speak five words with my understanding, that by my voice I might teach others also, than ten thousand words in an unknown tongue. Brethren, be not children in understanding; howbeit in malice be ye children, but in understanding be men" (1 Cor. 14:18-20).
The least that can be looked for in those who minister is acquaintance with the Scripture, the understanding of God’s mind as revealed in the Word. Observe that there may be this without any gift of utterance, without any capacity to communicate it to others. But without this, what have we to communicate? God’s saints are surely not assembled from time to time in the name of Jesus to have crude and undigested human thoughts presented to them, or to have retold to them what others have spoken or written. Personal acquaintance with God’s Word, familiarity with Scripture, understanding of its contents, is surely essential to the ministry of the Word. When our Lord was about to send out His disciples as His witnesses, it is said, "Then opened He their understanding, that they might understand the Scriptures" (Luke 24:45).
How often we read of Paul, when preaching to the Jews, reasoning with them out of the Scriptures (Acts 18:4,19). If the apostle addresses the Romans as able to admonish one another, it is because he can say of them, "And I myself also am persuaded of you, my brethren, that ye also are full of goodness, filled with all knowledge, able also to admonish one another" (Rom. 15:14). If you look at the armor to be put on by the believer, you will find truth as a girdle for the loins, and "the sword of the Spirit, which is the Word of God" (Eph. 6:14-17). If you consider the qualifications of the bishop or overseer you will find:."Holding fast the faithful Word as he hath been taught, that he may be able by sound doctrine both to exhort and to convince the gainsayers" (Titus 1:9).
From all this it is evident, my brethren, that it is not merely by little scraps of truth, brought out whenever some impulse to that end visits us, that the church is to be edified. No, they by whom the Holy Spirit acts to feed and nourish and guide the saints of God are they whose souls are exercised habitually in the Word of God_they "who by reason of use have their senses exercised to discern both good and evil" (Heb. 5:14).
However, knowledge of God’s Word is not sufficient. There must be its present application to the consciences of the saints to meet their present need. For this there must be either acquaintance with their state (and this could never be very perfect or accurate), or else direct guidance from God. This is true of those who are in the fullest sense, and most manifestly, the gifts of Christ to His Church, as evangelists, pastors, or teachers. It is God only who can guide them to those portions of truth which will reach the conscience and meet the need of souls. It is He only who can enable them to present the truth in such a way as to secure these ends. God the Holy Spirit knows the need of each and all in the assembly; and He can guide those who speak to speak the suited, needed truth, whether they have the knowledge of the state of those addressed or not. How important, then, is implicit and unfeigned subjection to Him.
One thing that always marks ministry in the Spirit is the prompting of personal affection for Christ. "Lovest thou Me?" was the thrice repeated question to Peter, connected with the injunction to feed Christ’s flock. "For the love of Christ constraineth us," Paul says. How different is this from the many motives that might influence us naturally. How important that we should be able each time we minister to say with a good conscience, "My motive for speaking was not a love of prominence, or force of habit, or a restlessness which could not be content unless something was being done, but love to Christ and to His flock."
Further, ministry and worship in the Spirit is always marked by a deep sense of responsibility to Christ. Suppose we were questioned after the close of a meeting, "Why did you give out such a hymn, or read such a chapter, or offer such a prayer, or speak such a word?" Could we with a clear, good conscience reply, "My only reason for doing so was the solemn conviction that it was my Master’s will"? My brethren, is there not often the taking this part or that without any sense of responsibility to Christ?
"If any man speak, let him speak as the oracles of God" (1 Peter 4:11). This is not an exhortation for one to speak according to the Scriptures, though all should, of course, do this. It says rather that they who speak are to speak as God’s mouthpiece. If I cannot say in speaking, "This is what I believe I have been taught of God, and what God has given me to speak at this time," I ought to be silent. Of course a man may be mistaken in saying this; but nothing less ought to induce anyone to take part in the meetings than the solemn conviction before God that God has given him something to say. If our consciences were exercised to act under such responsibility as this, it would doubtless prevent a great deal which does take place; but at the same time it would make way for God to manifest His presence as we are not accustomed to witness it.
One other point I would mention. A man may have little or no human learning, he may be unable to express himself in any elegant diction, or even with grammatical propriety. All this he may lack, and yet be a good minister of Jesus Christ if he is acquainted with the Word and subject to the leading of the Holy Spirit.
May the Lord in His mercy, beloved brethren, grant us to walk humbly with Himself, and thus may no hindrance be presented to the working of His blessed Spirit among us.
(Condensed from Five Letters on Worship and Ministry in the Spirit.)