Blackheath, August, 1875.
My Beloved Friends,
According to promise, I propose
now to take up the question of the Old Testament saints. In point of fact, if
the church was not formed until Pentecost, and is completed at the coming of
the Lord, the millennial saints will also be outside the church. But as all the
feeling is shown on the subject of the Old Testament class, and the principle
is the same in both cases, we will confine our attention mainly to these.
That Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, and
all the saints under the old dispensation, were quickened, devoted servants of
God, and that they will share in the first resurrection, with all the believers
of this dispensation, at the coming of Christ, every instructed saint will at
once admit, because this much is plain from the word of God. But we dare not go
beyond the word, and if God has concealed from us the place in the glory which
these eminent servants of His will occupy, it is the part of piety to bow in
submission, to reverence His silence as well as His word. Moreover, it savors
not only of insubmission and irreverence, but it derogates also from the
sufferings of Christ and from the grace and work of the Spirit to maintain that
the saints who lived before the atonement was completed and before the descent
of the Holy Ghost, and who consequently had not the indwelling Spirit, are in
precisely the same position as those who live now. Besides, I hope to show you
that the Scriptures themselves make a distinction; and if so, the difficulty
ought at once to be removed.
I will cite, in the first place,
Matt. 11:11, where we read, "Among them that are born of women there hath
not risen a greater than John the Baptist:notwithstanding he that is least in
the kingdom of heaven is greater than he." It would lead us away from our
object to enter here upon a full exposition of this passage, and hence I will
content myself with calling your attention to the fact that the Lord tells us
that eminent as John the Baptist was in the position assigned him by God as the
forerunner of and the testifier to the coming Messiah, the very least in the
kingdom of heaven is greater. Be the difference what it may—a dispensational
difference, no doubt—the Lord Jesus does here make a distinction between
saints; and not only so, but in this distinction He contrasts one of the least
in the coming kingdom with one of the greatest before that time, and to the
advantage of the former.
Secondly, let us turn to Romans
3:24-26:"Being justified freely by His grace through the redemption that
is in Christ Jesus:Whom God hath set forth [to be] a propitiation through
faith in His blood, to declare His righteousness for the remission of sins
that are past, through the forbearance of God; To declare, I say, at this
time His righteousness:that He might be just, and the justifier of him which
believeth in Jesus." Now, mark at the very outset that the word remission
in the text is given as passing over in the margin, and this is the
correct translation; and this word is never used of the forgiveness of sins in
connection with faith in Christ; indeed it is not elsewhere found in the New
Testament and means, as explained in the margin, a passing by, or
pretermission. Bearing this in mind, you will perceive that we have a contrast
between the position of the Old Testament saints as to the forgiveness of sins,
and the position of believers since the death of Christ. In the former case,
their sins were passed over, or pretermitted, through the forbearance of
God; in the latter, God is said to be just and the justifier of him
which believeth in Jesus. Surely this is a plain distinction between Old Testament
saints and believers of the present dispensation; for sins passed over through
the forbearance of God, because of the coming sacrifice of Christ, can never
express the condition of those who, "being justified by faith . . . have
peace with God through our Lord Jesus Christ:By whom also we have access by
faith into this grace wherein we stand, and rejoice in hope of the glory of
God" (Rom. 5:1, 2); and of those who are said to be seated "together
in heavenly places in Christ" (Eph. 2:6); and of those of whom the Apostle
John could say, "As He is, so are we in this world." (I John
4:1?)
We pass on now to the Hebrews;
and there we have these words:"These all" (the Old Testament
saints), "having obtained a good report through faith, received not the promise:
God having provided some better thing for us, that they without us
should not be made perfect." (Heb. 11:39, 40) Here also we have a
statement, as plain as language can make it, that believers in the present
dispensation receive some "better thing" than fell in the sovereignty
and grace of God to the Old Testament believers.
Having called your attention to
these direct teachings of Scripture, I will now adduce another class of
passages, in which we shall find saints in a perfected condition but outside
the church. The only thing I need to premise is that the church is the
bride of Christ. All, I should suppose, are agreed as to this. Let us then turn
to Revelation nineteen. In the seventh and eighth verses we have the wife of
the Lamb; and then, in the ninth, these words follow:"Blessed are they
which are called" (or invited; see John 2:2) "unto the marriage
supper of the Lamb." Thus we have a class spoken of who are invited; not
the wife, but the called—those who were guests at the marriage supper.
Turn again to chapter 21:
"And I John saw the holy city, new Jerusalem, coming down from God out of
heaven, prepared as a bride adorned for her husband. And I heard a great voice
out of heaven saying, Behold, the tabernacle of God is with men, and He will
dwell with them," etc. (vv. 2, 3) In the ninth verse, this city, the holy
Jerusalem, is said to be "the bride, the Lamb’s wife"; but in the
above passage it is described also as "the tabernacle of God," and
this tabernacle is said to be with men; so that once more we have saints
in a perfected condition outside the church.
And I would also remind you,
that you have for some years professed to hold the premillennial coming of the
Lord Jesus. If you do still, then of necessity, since the church is completed
at the coming of Christ for His people (for the marriage of the Lamb is
previous to the millennial reign), the millennial saints—innumerable for
multitude—do not form part of the church; and so, in any case, a large class on
your own ground is excluded. There is no more "injustice," therefore,
done to the Old Testament saints than to the millennial believers when the
proper position and privileges of the church are maintained.
The subject however would not be
completely discussed, if we did not refer to some two or three passages which
might, at first sight, seem to have an opposite bearing. The first of these is
Matt. 8:11, 12:"And I say unto you, That many shall come from the east
and west, and shall sit down with Abraham, and Isaac, and Jacob, in the kingdom
of heaven. But the children of the kingdom shall be cast out into outer
darkness," etc. In the first place, if this did refer to the church,
sitting down with the patriarchs in the kingdom of heaven does not prove that
the patriarchs belonged to the church. No one, we suppose, doubts that
believers will see Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob in the kingdom; the only question
is, Are they of the church? But it is evident that this passage says nothing of
the church. If so, how could "the children of the kingdom" be cast
out? No, Jesus speaks as the Messiah, and in this character He warns the
unbelieving Jews, that their descent from the patriarchs will avail them
nothing; that, though they were the children of those to whom the promises were
made, they would, if they rejected Him, be cast out; and that, just as the
centurion, whose servant He had healed, had pressed by faith into the
possession of blessing, so should numbers from all quarters press into the
kingdom when it should be set up, and should thus obtain, by faith, the blessed
privilege which they were now despising.
The only other passage which
occasions any difficulty is in the Epistle to the Galatians. It is as follows:
"So then they which be of faith are blessed with faithful Abraham."
(Gal. 3:9) The theme of the apostle in this chapter is justification by faith;
and he shows, first, that Abraham was justified by faith (v. 6), and then that
the same principle obtains under the gospel, and consequently that every one
who is of faith is blessed with faithful, i.e. believing, Abraham. (See
also Romans 4.) The question therefore dealt with is the principle on
which God justifies, not the position into which the justified are brought; and
hence this passage does not go farther than teach that the mode in which
Abraham was justified is that in which believers now are justified; and
therefore it does not touch upon dispensational differences of any kind.
Having thus passed, though
briefly, the whole subject in review, we see that the Scriptures say nothing as
to the inclusion of the Old Testament saints in the church; and that the
Scriptures themselves make a plain distinction between the saints of the two
dispensations. At the same time we repeat that, since we know they were born of
God, quickened by the power of the Spirit through faith, they belong to Christ,
though not members of His body, and will, therefore, share in the first
resurrection together with the church. Beyond this we may not go, as the
Scriptures are silent as to the place in the glory they will occupy; and I am
sure that you, equally with myself, would be the first to reject such
speculations as are sometimes offered upon the question as to whether some
change might not be wrought upon the patriarchs’ condition after the death of
Christ, so as to bring them into the church; for, in truth, this is to fall, in
principle, into the popish error of purgatory, even though it be shorn of its
grossest features. No, our part is to accept whatever the Scriptures may teach,
and as implicitly to refuse any speculation which seeks to penetrate into the
things which God has not revealed.
But since He has taught us that
the period of the church is included between Pentecost and the coming of the
Lord, we know that the believers before and the believers after that time
cannot form part of it, cannot be members of the body of Christ. Their place
and blessing in the glory will be worthy of Him who separated them unto
Himself, and will call forth their adoration and praise, equally with ours, as
they contemplate the wondrous display of the riches of His grace in their
salvation and eternal glory.
Believe me, beloved friends,
Yours affectionately in Christ,
E. Dennett